Smart Locks vs. Traditional Locks: Pros, Cons, and Locksmiths’ Perspectives

In the world of home and business security, the smart lock vs traditional lock debate is getting more and more relevant. Each type of lock has its pros and cons, and knowing these will help you make an informed decision on the best security solution for you. 

In this article, we will compare and contrast smart locks and traditional locks, with insights from professional locksmiths on the benefits, drawbacks and security implications.

Smart Locks

Pros:

1. Convenience:

• Smart locks are super convenient with features like remote access, keyless entry and integration with home automation systems. You can lock and unlock your door with your smartphone app, voice command or a connected device.

Access Control:

• Smart locks allow you to control access better. You can grant temporary access to guests, service providers or family members and see who’s entering and exiting your home through the lock’s activity log.

Extra Security Features:

• Many smart locks have extra security features like tamper alerts, auto lock and integration with security cameras and alarm systems, a complete security solution.

Customisable:

• With smart locks you can often customise access codes and set schedules for when certain codes are active, making it easier to manage different users’ access.

Cons:

1. Technology Dependence:

• Smart locks rely on technology and internet connectivity, so they can be hacked, glitchy and prone to power outages. If the battery dies or the system fails, access can be compromised.

More Expensive:

• Smart locks are generally more expensive than traditional locks. Some models require subscription services or additional features that cost extra.

More Complicated Installation:

• Installing a smart lock is more complicated than a traditional lock, often requiring professional installation to make sure it works and is properly integrated with other systems.

Privacy Issues:

• The data collected by smart locks (access logs) can be a privacy concern. If this data isn’t stored securely it can be accessed by unauthorised people.

Traditional Locks

Pros:

1. Reliability:

• Traditional locks are mechanical and don’t rely on electricity or internet connectivity, so they work in any situation, power outages and network failures.

Cost Effective:

• Generally traditional locks are cheaper than smart locks. No additional subscriptions or technological maintenance is required, and a cost-effective security solution.

Easy to Use:

• Traditional locks are easy to use and install. Most people are familiar with how they work and they don’t require apps or devices to function.

Fewer Security Risks:

• Because traditional locks are not connected to the internet they can’t be hacked. Simplicity can be an advantage in security terms.

Cons:

1. Limited Access Control:

• Traditional locks don’t offer the same level of access control as smart locks. Managing multiple keys and making sure they don’t fall into the wrong hands can be a challenge.

No Remote Access:

• You can’t control or monitor a traditional lock remotely. Lack of connectivity can be a disadvantage for those who want to manage their security from afar.

Key Management:

• Keys can be lost, stolen or duplicated without your knowledge, posing a security risk. Rekeying locks can also be a hassle and an extra cost.

No Advanced Features:

• Traditional locks don’t have the advanced features of smart locks like integration with other security devices, activity logs and custom access settings.

Locksmiths’ Perspectives

Tony’s Locksmith Cardiff gives us the practical lowdown on both smart and traditional locks. Here’s what some locksmiths say:

On Smart Locks:

• Security: While smart locks have advanced features, some locksmiths warn about security risks due to hacking and software bugs. Choose reputable brands and keep the firmware updated.
• Installation and Maintenance: Locksmiths stress the importance of proper installation. A poorly installed smart lock can be easier to bypass than a well-installed traditional lock. Regular maintenance and battery checks are also necessary to keep it working.

On Traditional Locks:

• Reliability: Many locksmiths say traditional locks are reliable. Less prone to technical failures and a more reliable option for those who prefer mechanical simplicity.
• Security Enhancements: Locksmiths often recommend combining traditional locks with additional security measures like deadbolts and security bars to add security without relying on digital technology.

Conclusion

It all depends on your needs, preferences and the level of security required. Smart locks offer modern conveniences and advanced features but with higher cost and technological risks. Traditional locks are cost-effective, reliable and easy to use but lack the fancy features of smart locks.

Talk to a locksmith to determine your security needs and choose the right lock for your home or business. Whether you choose smart or traditional locks, proper installation and maintenance are key.